I’m a sucker for a good ghost story. I’ve been known to book rooms in haunted hotels, attend a séance or two and count orbs after photographing places known for paranormal activity. I’d like to think that the testimonies of countless witnesses to the unexplained are true, but the farthest reaches of my rational brain remain skeptical. That said, the foothills of Appalachia have a way of loosening your grip on certainty.

Mt. Nebo Lore
The best place to start if you want to understand Athens County’s relationship with the supernatural is the fifth floor of Ohio University’s Alden Library. Tucked away in the Robert E. and Jean R. Mahn Center for Archives and Special Collections is what Athens journalist and author Sharon Hatfield calls the Spook File — a folder with page after page of newspaper clippings documenting the area’s alleged paranormal activity. It reads like a field guide to the local haunts you probably won’t want visit after dark, such as Mt. Nebo.
Hatfield spent years piecing together Mt. Nebo lore for her book Enchanted Ground: The Spirit Room of Jonathan Koons. In it, she details the true story of farmer-turned-medium Jonathan Koons, who was compelled to build a log cabin on Mt. Nebo, where he would summon spirits.
In the 1850s, the Spirit Room soon became a magnet for true believers of spiritualism, determined skeptics and people who came just for the entertainment value. Witnesses claimed that musical instruments would play on their own, messages would appear on paper faster than any human could write and disembodied hands would glow in the dark.
The cabin is long gone, and its exact location remains a mystery even Hatfield hasn’t fully solved. “I think I’m getting closer to finding the answer,” Hatfield told me. “I’ve consulted experts and put together possible clues. I hope with LiDAR and other archaeological tools we may discover its actual location.”
The site is generally mapped at the intersection of Sand Ridge Road and Mill Creek Road in Dover Township — a short drive north of Athens. Some people who have ventured into the area have reported seeing strange lights or orbs in the area or experienced the pull of its spiritual magnetism. At a talk Hatfield gave, one audience member said she felt a “distinct psychic shift.”
Hatfield herself never felt it. “I appreciate spiritual curiosity,” she said, “and I believe there is magic in the universe.”

Travel through Moonville Tunnel
If Mt. Nebo leaves you wanting more, the back roads of southeast Ohio will oblige. Getting to Moonville Tunnel takes commitment even before you reach it. Cell service disappears and the last stretch of Hope-Moonville Road narrows to dirt and gravel along a cliff edge above Raccoon Creek. First-timers turn around. Don’t.
Park at the small lot off Hope-Moonville Road, cross the footbridge over the creek, then follow the old railbed. The tunnel doesn’t announce itself; it just appears. A graffiti-covered brick arch guards a seemingly endless black hole that swallows the remaining light of day filtering through the dense forest canopy.
As the legend goes, a brakeman, who worked with the Marietta and Cincinnati Railroad in the 1800s, fell beneath a train near the tunnel and was killed. His ghost swings his lantern in the dark, using the same warning signal he used in life. The railroad eventually had to install a signal at Moonville because engineers kept throwing their trains into emergency braking when they spotted the light.
If you want to ride in rather than walk, Uncle Buck’s Riding Stable in New Marshfield runs guided horseback rides through Zaleski State Forest directly to the tunnel. The two-hour ride follows trails once used by miners and rail workers, who lived and worked along them. You’ll actually ride through the tunnel itself, into the dark and out the other side, to where the old town of Moonville once stood. After, there’s slow-cooked barbecue and cold beverage waiting back at the outfitter’s Old West-style Lady Buck Saloon.
I didn’t see the Moonville ghosts either time I went to Moonville Tunnel, but standing inside it, with cold air moving through it, definitely gave me the chills.
Laura Watilo Blake is an award-winning travel writer and photography from Ohio who’s explored natural wonders around the state and counts Moonville Tunnel among her favorite destinations.
